The Pony Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to The Pony, a culinary gem nestled in Cincinnati, where comfort food meets vibrant atmosphere. As you step inside, expect to find a diverse menu that truly satisfies every craving. The heart of their offerings is undeniably the wings, notably the habanero garlic wings, described as a spicy, teriyaki delight that has captured the hearts (and taste buds) of many patrons.
- Beef on weck has garnered rave reviews, paired perfectly with creamy horseradish for the ultimate flavor experience.
- And don’t miss out on the pizza logs and handcut fries, a perfect accompaniment to any meal.
- The drink selection includes refreshing cocktails and a variety of beers, ensuring the perfect sip to complement your dining experience.
Whether you’re here for game day or a casual night out, The Pony promises to deliver a fantastic meal in a welcoming setting. Don't forget to arrive early, especially on busy days, to truly relish their offerings!
Drafts
Lift
Psychopathy
Happy Amber
Psa
Pilgrim
S'mores Stout
The Old Work Horse Bourbon
Ginger maple simple, lemon biters
Pony Express Grape Vodka
Blue curaceo, lemonade, grenadine
Continental Colt Vodka/Kahlua
Cinnamon toast crunch cereal milk
Hot Cider
W/bourbon or rum
Bloody Mary
Irish Coffee
Classics
Made with fine spirits price adjusted for top shelf
Well Drinks
Cocktails
Bottle Beer
Milier Lite
Budweiser
Michelob Light
Modelo Especial
Mia Mega Mix Pale Ale
Original Sin Apple Cider
Dogfish Head Sequench
Molson Golden
Molson Canadian
Jever Pilsner
Jackie O's Mystic Momma Ipa
Miller High Life
Double Ipa
Stout
Euro
Double Ipa
Stout
Euro
Of The Month
Wine
Red
Rose
White
Turkey Club
Lettuce, tomato, onion, house mayo, bacon and sliced egg
Roast Beef
Tomato, onion, house mayo, cheese, side of fresh horseradish
Chicken Finger Sub
Lettuce, tomato, house mayo, house blue cheese